What have I got?

[Shellkat]

Hi friends! I took this pretty bugger to a show last week and it was identified Alley by Mr Alley himself. On the other side of the room I found one that looked remarkably similar. I said, "I have an Alley like that." But he said, "that's a CAC." I showed him mine and we noted the similarities. I know how iffy ids can be (and how iffy my pictures tend to be haha) but I still left quite confused, and of course didn't ask enough questions. Thanks!

[Steph]

This is the one he said Alley on?

That's comforting, because my immediate first thought was Alley.

 

Which one did he say CAC on?  Did you get a picture of that one?

[Shellkat]

Yes. : )  I didn't take a picture of the other one. It just looked like his brother,enough for me to stop and say hey.  And not much more was said after we compared them. But thanks for the confidence in the Alley Id. : )

[Shellkat]

9 minutes ago, Steph said:

This is the one he said Alley on?

That's comforting, because my immediate first thought was Alley.

 

Which one did he say CAC on?  Did you get a picture of that one?

It was a different table/dealer/collector at the show that had the other one.  Which could be anything, it just really looked like mine.  Mr. Alley said mine was Alley, and my mom and I really liked him--he was very informative and willing to talk to us goofballs. We also won the door prize at the show: 20 assorted, SWEET, Akro Agate corks! 

[Steph]

LOL ... that's a day to remember ...