If you check out Cheese new WV swirl book it shows a few different examples of carnivals. I’ve seen variations but all of them must have black. I’ve only seen two in the wild in 2 years of collection hard.
Unfortunately IMHO not a Carnival. Here’s one of ours but I think Chad didn’t think it was one? But I’m fairly sure it is
Some think the carnival is the holy grail of Alleys? Not sure about that but I’ve only seen 2