Need advice on this potential lot of marbles

[marblemanvintagemarbles]

The fella was asking $200 for the lot but Idk that German looks to be very nice. 

[cheese]

That German is the only thing I see with any significant value but it also is questionable to me. I'd want close clear detailed photos, especially of the pontils. 

[marblemanvintagemarbles]

Im gonna ask him for some better pictures. It looks immaculate in the photos. If it's not polished in that good of condition and it's legit that looks like it could be quite the flip. But im in the fence 

1 hour ago, cheese said:

That German is the only thing I see with any significant value but it also is questionable to me. I'd want close clear detailed photos, especially of the pontils. 

 

[Fire1981]

I call these Baited groups or auctions. One marble that draws you into bidding on a group of commons. If you like that hand made? Find one that might be a single listing you like and avoid 10-20 common marbles your not that interested in🔥

RAR

[Fire1981]

$200 is insane. $10-$20 max and I think that’s generous. We’ll see what others have to say🔥

RAR

[Carowill]

I’m with Fire.  Not a $200 grouping in my opinion.

[William]

Pass....

[VaMarbles]

Looks like an Indian in the last picture and those are selling for $15-25.  Hard pass for $200 on the lot  

 

[cheese]

That one looks to be over an inch and wet if not polished and real. If so, that's not a $15-25 marble. Probably not $200 though.

[marblemanvintagemarbles]

I thought that Indian may be worth a bit more than the 200 but wasn't sure

[VaMarbles]

1 hour ago, cheese said:

That one looks to be over an inch and wet if not polished and real. If so, that's not a $15-25 marble. Probably not $200 though.

Did not notice the size of that Indian Cheese. Good catch.  Yes at that size and colors on two sides it’s probably over $100 in my opinion.  Pictures are kinda vague for ID.  The first picture looks more like a master than an Indian.