Agree on the date on the Tiger Eyes, some time in the 50's. I'd guess earlier rather than later.
Agree not Cracker Jack on the maybe-pelts. Cracker Jacks did have some largish prizes - in the early days. But pretty sure marbles weren't among their prizes during the cat eye age. Not sure when Pelt introduced their cats. (I think 1954 or later.)
The only Cracker Jack marble prize I remember seeing was a single marble wrapped like a piece of hard candy, circa 1928.
Nifty items you have there ... as usual!!!