At the far end of the scale where a "precision banded Indian" starts to look like a "banded transparent". Due to the base glass. And the white stripes. That would look nice with some Indians for sure.
Chuck, I was talking about the first one you posted. The clear base shows almost a "wirepull" pattern, which you wouldn't see if the base was opaque..Does it look that way in hand?
Now you got me thinking on how this could occur on rollers, which would normally make marbles round/spherical. These nubs actually protrude and are 180 from eachother. They look a bit different than standard touch marks or cold rolls so maybe it is 1/3 of a barbell or some other factory reject. But not a cane cut one, drat I'll have to keep looking. lol
Could be now that you mention it. It's more of a German Sparkler I guess for lack of a better name. It would roll a certain way or else skip! Stuck to other ones on the rollers is a possibility. hmm
Lol, just joking. What an oddball, check this out. No machine rounding on this one. May be reworked with a torch (look at that/those punty marks) on opposite poles. Thought it might be good for an ogle. How did it happen you ask? I do not know. Non-faceted.
Here's a quick pic, The one in the middle is probably closer to what you mean. The right one is likely unintentional. Instead of being a "round" latt, picture it "flat"... like a ribbon, lol Hope that helps.
Hm, interesting. Sometimes we'd play 1 good marble for a few average ones to make it "even", but most times the marble you were playing for had to be in the game. Then once you win they get blindly tossed in the marble bag with dozens of others to rattle around and get damaged. lol
In my days on the playground if you wanted to win a good one you'd have to play a good one. Plenty of the 'good ones' got chipped in battle. Some people played the basic game, but when there were 'good ones' involved it usually involved a crowd.
Putting a grade to anything (unless you know very well what you're talking about - it seems marbles don't fall into a popular category) is subjective at best. Lol Alan, it's true. From the pics I thought maybe mint+ means "better than my pics look"